HomePublications

Reductionist and integrative research approaches to complex water security policy challenges

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Open Access permissions

Open

Documents

  • Manuscript

    Accepted author manuscript, 969 KB, PDF-document

DOI

Authors

  • Mark Zeitoun
  • Bruce Lankford
  • Tobias Krueger
  • Tim Forsyth
  • Richard Carter
  • Arjen Y Hoekstra
  • Richard Taylor
  • Olli Varis
  • Frances Cleaver
  • Rutgerd Boelens
  • Larry Swatuk
  • David Tickner
  • Christopher A Scott
  • Naho Mirumachi
  • Nathanial Matthews

Organisational units

Abstract

This article reviews and contrasts two approaches that water security researchers employ to advance understanding of the complexity of water-society policy challenges. A prevailing reductionist approach seeks to represent uncertainty through calculable risk, links national GDP tightly to hydro-climatological causes, and underplays diversity and politics in society. When adopted uncritically, this approach limits policy-makers to interventions that may reproduce inequalities, and that are too rigid to deal with future changes in society and climate. A second, more integrative, approach is found to address a range of uncertainties, explicitly recognise diversity in society and the environment, incorporate water resources that are less-easily controlled, and consider adaptive approaches to move beyond conventional supply-side prescriptions. The resultant policy recommendations are diverse, inclusive, and more likely to reach the marginalised in society, though they often encounter policy-uptake obstacles. The article concludes by defining a route towards more effective water security research and policy, which stresses analysis that matches the state of knowledge possessed, an expanded research agenda, and explicitly addresses inequities.

Details

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)143–154
JournalGlobal Environmental Change
Volume39
Early online date2 Jun 2016
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jul 2016
Peer-reviewedYes

Keywords

    Research areas

  • water security, environmental complexity, uncertainty, water conflicts, eco-sociological challenges

Bibliographic note

Early title: Reductive and integrative research approaches to complex water security policy challenges

View graph of relations

ID: 74371884